Advantages and disadvantages of Charcoal vs. Propane Grilling

This is a reader-supported website. By clicking on product links, you help us keep producing independent objective analysis at no cost to you. Thanks for your support!

Charcoal vs propane grilling, a debate that has been around for ages. If you or someone you know is a grilling enthusiast, then you probably have your own and have heard various opinions on the matter.

Today, we will be going through a few of the advantages and disadvantages of each to help you make more informed decisions and cement your stance on which one is best for you.


Charcoal Grill

One of the best things about a charcoal grill is going to be its cost. You can easily find a charcoal grill for under $100 and even less if you know where to look. Charcoal gives you that fire-cooked feeling and taste.

Pro: Charcoal grills aren’t only affordable, but portable enough to carry to certain activities like camping, hiking, etc. It is much more mobile when compared with gas grills.

Con: Users will have to install a charcoal chimney in the area where they are going to use it. For those who don’t know, it is a cylinder that has a grate in the inner portion. Buying this will result in adding extra costs to your budget.

Pro: There are flavors available in the smoke created by a charcoal grill. If you are looking for that true grilled flavor, you will find it with a charcoal grill. Just make sure you don’t use too much lighter fluid because it can alter the taste.

Con: Cleaning a charcoal goal is a very messy task that takes lots of time for completion. It is one of the main reasons that people avoid buying this version of a grill.

Pro: Charcoal grills can get really hot. The coals can be stoked until they are at 700 degrees Fahrenheit. This is much hotter than most gas grills, and it allows you to achieve that perfect sear on each and every steak.

Con: Charcoal grills heat up slowly, so they require a good amount of patience as well as practice to make sure you get to the right temperature for perfect grilling.

Propane Gas Grill

A propane gas grill can be a bit more complicated to use than a charcoal grill at times because they often have many more features to learn. However, once you get used to it, you will find that propane grills are easy to use and very convenient.

Pro: You will be amazed to know that using a propane grill is as easy as using a stove. There is a dial-in every burner that is very easy to customize. Cooking can be enjoyed with minimum caution while chatting with friends. You don’t have to devote as much attention to a gas grill as you would to your charcoal grill.

Con: Propane grills need fuel to run that can put a great burden on your pocket. On top of that, fuel is a nonrenewable source that won’t last forever. However, propane is one of the more affordable gas options to choose from. You can also opt to add a natural gas line to your grill, but this will be an added expense.

Pro: Propane grills are very quick to heat up and don’t involve too many hassles. It usually only takes about half an hour for a propane grill to get hot, but most of the time, your desired temperature can be achieved in as little as fifteen minutes.

Furthermore, cleaning them after cooking is much easier when compared with the charcoal grills.

Con: There is a need for a pretty larger space for keeping a propane grill due to its size. That is why it is considered appropriate only for outdoor grilling.

Which One to Choose?

A propane gas grill is becoming a more popular option for many homes and outdoor gatherings because they are built to cook with propane and can easily be converted to natural gas without much hassle if that is something you are interested in doing.

Propane grills have also proven to be a more affordable option in the long run, although the initial expense up front will most likely be more than that of a charcoal grill.

When determining what to choose between a charcoal and propane grill, it really comes down to your personal preferences and what you like to grill. For example, if you use your grill for smoke roasting, then you may want a charcoal grill because there will be a noticeable difference in the flavor of what you are smoking when compared to propane grilling. You can also mix charcoal with the smoke from wood chips or wood pellets to get a more distinct flavor.

Overall, you will find that grills are used for a variety of cooking, including high heat direct radiation cooking, indirect heat convection roasting, and indirect heat smoke roasting.

If you are looking for more direct heat grilling and want to make things like flavored rubs, marinades, and sauces, then you won’t even notice any of the taste differences in charcoal versus propane grilling. So, you should definitely keep this in mind as well as you make your selection.

Charcoal Grill Combo

Still can’t decide between a gas and charcoal grill? Why not look into a charcoal grill combo? Instead of having to make the tough choice between charcoal vs gas, consider the advantages of having both at your disposal. A gas and charcoal combo allows grilling with charcoal briquettes and wood chips, as well as gas. So, you get the world of delicious, smoky flavor combined with better temperature control, easy cleaning, and quicker cooking times. You can take advantage of all the benefits of all-weather cooking and even more fuel options, which can ultimately save you money and space.

Before purchasing a charcoal grill combo, determine the amount of food you think you will be cooking. You can also choose different features that may prove helpful such as a warming rack to keep the food warm until it is time to be served.

Also, look into BTUs. This is an indication of the amount of heat that is generated along with the accompanying fuel consumption of the grill. Finally, make sure you check dimensions to ensure you have adequate space for your new charcoal grill combo.

We hope all the information we have provided today goes a long way in helping you settle on charcoal vs propane grilling.

Eric Arnow